November 22, 2010 § Leave a comment
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I heard such great things about this book and it was recommended to me by more than one person so I was really hoping that I would like it a lot more than I did.
What was good: The audio book narrator was wonderful. She had the perfect, and I mean PERFECT Georgia accent for MacKayla Lane. A lot of what got me through the book was the great narration. The plot was interesting, Mackayla makes her way to Ireland in search of her sister’s murderer and finds out that everything she believed about herself and the world was wrong and that she really didn’t know too much about her sister at all. She meets some pretty awful characters/things/creatures and a few fairly rude “friends” along the way. The effects that certain fae have on humans were quite interesting. There is one particular scene in the museum that had me laughing out loud. All in all, the plot was intriguing enough to get me from start to finish while keeping my attention.
But it wasn’t amazing. When I stopped listening, I didn’t find myself eager to get back to it so I could find out what happens next. I think that a lot of my problem with this book comes down to my love of traditional fantasy, and although I do like a unique re-imagining of things, I simply cannot buy into the “fae are aliens” thing. I honestly did not like that aspect of the book at all and is the main reason why I won’t be continuing the series. I had no issues with the writing itself. I didn’t find it to be overly descriptive, the dialog fit with the situations and wasn’t overdone. Even the fact that Mackayla talked a lot about her clothes and could be a bit immature, I felt that would most likely lead to her really growing as a character in later books.
So, for anyone who would enjoy a book where the fae are aliens and some come in a many-armed many-mouthed variety, I would recommend this book. Its simply not for me.